Free Shipping All Orders Over $149+
We Ship Your Orders Every Wednesday! Please order by Sunday for on-time delivery.
-
Guggisberg Baby Swiss Cheese, 1/2 (0.5) lb
Regular price $12.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Sold outGuggisberg Baby Swiss Cheese, 2 lb
Regular price $38.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Sold outHigh Quality Amish Butter , 1 lb
Regular price $25.99Regular priceUnit price per -
John F. Martin & Sons Original Ring Bologna, 16 oz
Regular price $14.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Kirchenberg Farm Kefir Blueberry, 32 oz. (946 ml)
Regular price $7.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Kirchenberg Farm Kefir Natural, 32 oz. (946 ml)
Regular price $7.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Kirchenberg Farm Kefir Strawberry, 32 oz. (946 ml)
Regular price $7.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Kirchenberg Farm Kefir Vanilla, 32 oz. (946 ml)
Regular price $7.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Chocolate Milk, 1 Gallon (3.78L)
Regular price $9.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Chocolate Milk, 1 Pint (0.473L)
Regular price $1.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Chocolate Milk, 1/2 Gallon (1.89L)
Regular price $5.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Fresh Brown Amish Eggs, 1 Dozen (12ct)
Regular price $9.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Home-Style Salted Butter, 1 lb
Regular price $13.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Low Fat Milk, 1 Gallon (3.78L)
Regular price $9.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Low Fat Milk, 1/2 Gallon (1.89L)
Regular price $5.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Skim Milk, 1 Gallon (3.78L)
Regular price $9.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Skim Milk, 1/2 Gallon (1.89L)
Regular price $5.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Whole Milk, 1 Gallon (3.78L)
Regular price $9.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Lapp Valley Farm Whole Milk, 1/2 Gallon (1.89L)
Regular price $5.49Regular priceUnit price per -
Meadow View Non-GMO High Quality Amish Eggs, 1 Dozen (12ct)
Regular price $11.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Minerva Dairy Sea Salt Roll Butter, 2 lb
Regular price $27.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Minerva Dairy Sea Unsalt Roll Butter, 2 lb
Regular price $27.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Pearl Valley Amish Country Hand-Rolled Butter - Salted, 1 lb (454g)
Regular price $14.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Pearl Valley Amish Country Hand-Rolled Butter - Salted, 2 lb (907g)
Regular price $26.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Pearl Valley Amish Country Rolled Butter - Unsalted, 1 lb (454g)
Regular price $14.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Pequea Valley Farm - Plain Yogurt, 32 oz (914g)
Regular price $9.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Pickling Cucumber (4 inch) from Amish Farm, 1 lb
Regular price $5.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Raw USA Clover Honey Dutch Gold, 16oz (454g)
Regular price $19.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Raw Wild Flower Honey with Comb, 8oz (227g)
Regular price $17.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Sold outSag Harbor Raw Honeycomb, 5oz (142g)
Regular price $18.99Regular priceUnit price per -
Seltzer's Smokehouse Meats Original Lebanon Bologna, 12 oz
Regular price $13.99Regular priceUnit price per -
September Farm Apple Butter, 9 oz (255g)
Regular price $10.99Regular priceUnit price per
